Cold calling for agencies works as a system, not a mood. Build a clean, compliant list, call from a dialer that shows a real callback number, open with a question, push past two objections and ask for a specific time. Then track dials, conversations and meetings that show, every day.
Most agency owners have a cold calling story. Someone made 30 calls, booked nothing and decided "cold calling is dead." Or they handed a new hire a spreadsheet and a phone, then blamed the person when nothing happened.
Cold calling isn't dead. Unstructured cold calling is. Our team has coached 700+ agencies in Canada, the US and Europe, and the ones that book meetings by phone share three habits: they build the machine before they hire the caller, they keep every call within the rules, and they review the numbers daily instead of monthly.
This guide covers the rules, the list, the dialer, the script, hiring a caller, pay and the numbers to track. It sits alongside our cold outreach guide, which covers email and in-person follow-up.
Does Cold Calling Still Work for Agencies?
Yes, for the right offer and buyer. Phone works best when:
- Your buyer answers their own phone. Owner-operated local businesses and founder-led companies are easier to reach than large companies with gatekeepers.
- Your offer is easy to explain in one sentence. "We help HVAC companies get more booked jobs" is something a busy owner can react to in 10 seconds.
- The deal is worth a conversation. A monthly retainer justifies a human call. A small one-off project usually doesn't.
Calls also land better when a prospect has seen your email or a post. If you're still choosing channels, start with our guide on how to get clients for your marketing agency. If your offer is fuzzy, fix positioning before you dial, using our guide to the agency business.
The Rules: What White-Hat Cold Calling Means
White-hat cold calling means you call real businesses about a real offer, say who you are, honour every "please don't call me again" and follow the rules in each country you call. Here's a plain-English summary. It isn't legal advice, so check with a lawyer if you're unsure.
| Market | What the rules say for B2B calls | What it means for your agency |
|---|---|---|
| Canada | Calls to business numbers are exempt from the National Do Not Call List rules but are still covered by the CRTC's Telemarketing Rules. Callers must identify themselves and the purpose of the call, display a number people can call back, and call only 9:00 a.m. to 9:30 p.m. on weekdays and 10:00 a.m. to 6:00 p.m. on weekends (CRTC) | Keep your own do-not-call list. Requests must be honoured within 14 days. Check the National DNCL rules before calling any number that may be a personal line |
| United States | Most calls to a business are exempt from the FTC's Telemarketing Sales Rule, but the bans on misrepresentation and on false or misleading statements still apply (16 CFR 310.6). The FCC has ruled that AI-generated voices count as "artificial" under the TCPA (FCC) | Live calls by a real person. No prerecorded or AI-voice cold calls, and no exaggerated claims about results |
| UK | Limited companies, PLCs and Scottish partnerships can register on the Corporate Telephone Preference Service (CTPS). You can't make marketing calls to numbers on it without clear consent (CTPS) | Screen every UK list against the CTPS (and TPS for sole traders) before calling. Elsewhere in Europe, check local rules first |
The short version: real people, real numbers, real claims, and a do-not-call list you actually use.
Step 1: Build the System Before You Hire a Caller
A strong salesperson dropped into a process that doesn't exist usually quits. Before anyone dials, put four things in place: a list, a dialer, a script and tracking.
Start with the leads you already own
The best first calls aren't cold at all. Most agencies are sitting on contacts nobody has phoned:
- People who opted in or requested a quote but never booked a call.
- Booked calls that no-showed.
- Proposals that went quiet in the last 12 months.
- Past clients and past contacts who said "not right now."
- People you met at events, or who replied to an email or post.
Then build a target account list by hand: businesses in your niche, researched one by one, using the main line published on their own website. 200 well-chosen companies beat 20,000 unchecked rows.
Split the list by priority
A caller who has to decide who to call next is a caller who isn't calling. Load the lists into your dialer or CRM in order so the next call is always obvious.
| Priority | Who's on it | When to call |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Hot | New opt-ins and inquiries that didn't book | Same day, first thing |
| 2. Warm | No-shows, quiet proposals, "call me next quarter" | Daily, after the hot list |
| 3. Follow-ups | Anyone a caller spoke to who asked to be called back | On the date they gave |
| 4. Cold | Hand-researched target accounts in your niche | The rest of the calling block |
Choose a dialer for the right reasons
Any brand will do if it's a power dialer that logs every dial, records calls for coaching (with disclosure where required) and shows a real number people can call back. Skip tools that promise to "beat spam filters" by cycling numbers. If your numbers get flagged, fix your list and opener instead.
Step 2: A Cold Call Script That Gets to a Question Fast
Bad calls are a monologue with no question, a polite exit at the first objection and no ask. Good calls follow four beats.
The four beats of a cold call: open with your name, agency and one question; qualify by asking what they do now for marketing; handle objections by acknowledging, reframing and asking again; and ask for a specific day and time
1. Open short, then ask a question
"Hi John, it's Sam from [Agency]. Quick one: are you taking on more [type of] work right now?"
Get to a question in the first 10 seconds. A yes opens the door to the next one: "Could you handle another 10 to 15 jobs a month?"
2. Qualify with one or two questions
"What are you doing for marketing at the moment? Have you worked with an agency before?"
If they've been burned by an agency before, acknowledge it. That's your opening for proof.
3. Handle the two objections you'll hear most
- "We're good on marketing." Acknowledge, reframe, ask again: "Totally fair. Most of the owners we work with said the same thing. The call is just 15 minutes to show what's working in [niche] right now. If it's not useful, you've lost nothing."
- "Just send me an email." "Happy to. Most people end up with more questions after the email, so let's do both. I'll send the info and we'll pencil in 15 minutes."
4. Ask for a specific time
Never ask "would you be open to a chat sometime?" Offer two options: "Does Monday at 9 or Tuesday at 2 work better?" Book it while you're on the phone, then send the invite and a short confirmation email with one relevant case study.
Book a call to map your cold calling system
Step 3: Hire a Caller Who Proves It in a Role Play
Interviews show you how well someone interviews. A role play shows you how they sell. In our free Cold Calling Systems that Convert video, the guest, who builds cold calling teams for agencies, shared a hiring funnel we now recommend:
- A landing page that sells the role, not just a job post.
- A written questionnaire to filter out people who apply to everything.
- A recorded video pitch on why they should be hired.
- A 15-minute phone screen: five minutes of questions, then a role play cold call with two objections built in.
- A final 30-minute interview about initiative and fit, once the skill is proven.
Score the role play on four things: do they get to a question fast, ask more than they talk, push past both objections and ask for a specific day and time? If the first objection ends the call, they're not the right fit, whatever their CV says. Expect hiring to take four to eight weeks.
Even if they'll close deals later, start them in appointment setting. For where this role sits in a small team, see our guide to a lean agency team structure.
Step 4: Pay for Meetings That Show, Not Meetings Set
You get the behaviour you pay for. Pay per meeting booked and you'll get a calendar full of no-shows. Pay salary only and there's no reason to push. The structure shared in our video has three parts:
| Pay component | Example shared in our video | Why it works |
|---|---|---|
| Base | US$2,000–3,000 a month | Covers living costs while the caller ramps up |
| Per qualified meeting that shows | About US$100 | Rewards booking the right people, not anyone |
| Per closed sale | About US$200, or a percentage of the deal | Ties the caller to revenue |
Adjust for your market and the caller's experience. The ratio matters more than the amounts.
Step 5: Track the Numbers Every Day
Dials should be checked daily, not monthly. The benchmarks from our video give you a starting point. Set your own baseline over the first month.
| Metric | Benchmark from our video | If it's low, check… |
|---|---|---|
| Dials per caller per day | 150 minimum | Activity. Is the calling block actually happening? |
| Connect rate | About 5% dialing by hand, 15–20% with a proper power dialer | The dialer, the list quality and call times |
| Conversations that book | 20–30% on a strong rep's best days | The opener and the ask |
| Meetings booked per day | 1–3 for a solid rep | All of the above |
| Show rate for cold-booked meetings | 30–35% is typical, 50% is excellent (opt-in leads often show at 60–70%) | Confirmation emails, reminders and qualification |
One story from the video: a caller blamed a "bad list" when the dialer showed 20 to 30 dials a day. His replacement used the same list and script, made 150+ dials a day and booked three to four demos a day. If a caller makes the dials and books nothing for two weeks, fix the script, offer, dialer or person.
Book a free call to review your outbound numbers
What Not to Do
Some cold calling advice crosses the line. We don't recommend any of it:
- Scraped or bought lists. You can't tell personal mobiles or do-not-call numbers from business lines.
- Rotating numbers to dodge spam labels. People must be able to see and call back the number you called from.
- Prerecorded or AI-voice cold calls. In the US, AI voices count as artificial under the TCPA. Keep calls human.
- Fake urgency or made-up results. Misrepresentation is banned even on US B2B calls.
- Ignoring "don't call me again." Add them to your internal do-not-call list the same day.
Results From Agencies We've Advised
None of these agencies relied on cold calling alone. In each case, we built the outbound scripts, objection handling and tracking that a calling system runs on. The numbers come from our published case studies.
| Agency | What we built | Result |
|---|---|---|
| Höski | Vertical positioning, clear packages, landing pages, outbound scripts and CRM tracking, a 4-week deal cycle | $15K to $50K/month in 4 months |
| Apex Leads | An offer built around booked meetings, a full sales system with outreach scripts, objection handling and sales tracking | $15K to $90K/month in 8 months, retention up from 30% to over 70% |
| Orizon | A 6-stage sales process with target account mapping, outbound sequencing and sales team training | $2M to $5.3M in annual revenue in 12 months, now closing $250K+ projects |
| OU2there | A move off 100% referrals: outbound partnerships, events, follow-up systems and a sharper discovery flow | First $70K outbound contract within 3 months |
The common thread: the offer and the process came first, and outreach volume came second. For bigger accounts, read our guide to landing enterprise clients.
Book a call to plan your outbound system
Watch the Full Video: Cold Calling Systems that Convert
Frequently Asked Questions
Does cold calling work for marketing agencies?
Yes, when the buyer answers their own phone, the offer fits in one sentence and the deal is worth a conversation. It works best as a system: a prioritised list, a dialer, a short script with objection handling and daily tracking of dials, conversations and meetings that show.
Is cold calling businesses legal in Canada and the US?
Generally yes, within the rules. In Canada, calls to business numbers are exempt from the National Do Not Call List rules but must follow the CRTC Telemarketing Rules, including calling hours and an internal do-not-call list. In the US, most B2B calls are exempt from the Telemarketing Sales Rule, but misrepresentation is still banned.
How many cold calls should an agency make per day?
The benchmark shared in our Cold Calling Systems video is at least 150 dials per caller per day, which a solid rep turns into 1 to 3 booked meetings. At 20 to 30 dials a day, a caller only reaches a handful of people, which isn't enough data to judge the list or the script.
What should an agency cold call script include?
A short opener with a question in the first 10 seconds, one or two qualifying questions, prepared answers to "we're good on marketing" and "just send me an email," and a closing ask for a specific day and time rather than a vague chat.
Should I hire a cold caller or make the calls myself?
Make the first calls yourself so you know the script works and what objections come up. Then hire once the list, dialer, script and tracking are in place. Test candidates with a role play that includes two objections, and pay a base plus commission on meetings that show and deals that close.
Can I use AI voices or prerecorded messages for cold calls?
We don't recommend it. In the US, the FCC has ruled that AI-generated voices count as artificial under the TCPA, which restricts calls using artificial or prerecorded voices. Keep cold calls live and human, and use AI for research and preparation instead.
Get Help Building Outbound That Books Meetings
A calling system only works when the offer, the script and the numbers line up. That's the work we do with agency owners every week, and our team has coached 700+ agencies in Canada, the US and Europe on exactly this.
- Marketing agency coaching: for owners who want to sharpen their offer, test a script themselves and then hire, test and pay a caller the right way.
- Agency consulting: for agencies that want our team to map the full outbound process with them: list, dialer, script, tracking and the sales process behind it.
If you're still building toward your first steady clients, our Agency Ignition program covers niche and offer clarity, sales training, outreach templates and the systems setup to get them.
Next steps: book a free strategy call to review your outbound numbers, or send us a message if you'd rather start in writing.

